CASEWard v. Polite

Client Story
Julea Ward

When Julea Ward walked into the room of professors from the counseling department, she hoped to find more tolerance than she’d received from her counseling supervisor at Eastern Michigan University. She was wrong.

Her counseling supervisor had already conducted an informal review of Julea, and now she had to endure another interrogation of her Christian faith from a review board of other faculty. Her offense? She referred a potential client who wanted advice on his same-sex relationship to another fellow counselor. Although she was willing to work with all clients, she could not affirm a relationship that was contrary to her faith. 


 

Unanimously, the school review board decided to expel her from the counseling program. Julea appealed, but her dismissal was upheld. Julea then contacted Alliance Defending Freedom, who helped her take legal action against the school.

This time, the court ruled in Julea’s favor, stating “Ward was willing to work with all clients and to respect the school’s affirmation directives in doing so. That is why she asked to refer gay and lesbian clients (and some heterosexual clients) if the conversation required her to affirm their sexual practices. What more could the [non-discrimination] rule require? Surely, for example, the ban on discrimination against clients based on their religion does not require a Muslim counselor to tell a Jewish client that his religious beliefs are correct if the conversation takes a turn in that direction and does not require an atheist counselor to tell a person of faith that there is a God if the client is wrestling with faith-based issues. Tolerance is a two-way street.”

Eastern Michigan University paid a settlement to Julea and removed the expulsion from her record.

Find out more about students' rights at universities.


Share this page
Summary
Eastern Michigan University has agreed to settle an Alliance Defending Freedom lawsuit filed on behalf of Julea Ward, a graduate student whom the university expelled from a counseling program for abiding by her religious beliefs. As a result, a federal district court issued an agreed-upon order of dismissal.
News Releases

EMU student achieves final victory after court rules ‘tolerance is a two-way street’

Religious Freedom

EMU student achieves final victory after court rules ‘tolerance is a two-way street’

University settles lawsuit after expelling counseling student for abiding by her beliefs

Dec 10, 2012 Read More

6th Circuit to EMU: ‘Tolerance is a two-way street’

Religious Freedom

6th Circuit to EMU: ‘Tolerance is a two-way street’

ADF attorneys represent Michigan graduate student expelled for her beliefs

Jan 27, 2012 Read More

Will EMU get away with expelling student who wouldn’t violate her beliefs to get a degree?

Religious Freedom

Will EMU get away with expelling student who wouldn’t violate her beliefs to get a degree?

ADF attorney available to media after oral argument at 6th Circuit Tuesday in case involving Michigan graduate student

Oct 03, 2011 Read More

E. Mich. Univ. ousts student for not affirming homosexual behavior

Religious Freedom

E. Mich. Univ. ousts student for not affirming homosexual behavior

ADF attorneys file suit on behalf of student expelled from graduate counseling program

Apr 03, 2009 Read More

Will university’s expulsion of Christian grad student stand?

Religious Freedom

Will university’s expulsion of Christian grad student stand?

Eastern Michigan University ousted student from counseling program for not affirming homosexual behavior; ADF attorney available to media after hearing

Jun 23, 2010 Read More

ADF to appeal ruling that allows Eastern Michigan U. to expel Christian students for holding to beliefs

Religious Freedom

ADF to appeal ruling that allows Eastern Michigan U. to expel Christian students for holding to beliefs

University banished graduate counseling student for not affirming homosexual behavior

Jul 27, 2010 Read More
Share this page
Documents
https://adflegal.blob.core.windows.net/web-content-dev/documents/ward-v-polite---appellate-court-opinion.pdf?sfvrsn=4https://adflegal.blob.core.windows.net/web-content-dev/documents/ward-v-polite---opinion.pdf?sfvrsn=6https://adflegal.blob.core.windows.net/web-content-dev/documents/ward-v-polite---order.pdf?sfvrsn=6https://adflegal.blob.core.windows.net/web-content-dev/documents/ward-v-polite---complaint.pdf?sfvrsn=6
Court Title Date
Appellate Court
Appellate Court Opinion Jan 27 2012
Trial Court
Opinion Jul 26 2010
Trial Court
Order Jul 26 2010
Trial Court
Complaint Apr 02 2009

Commentary

Resources

Biographies

Related Cases