BLOGHow Your Church Pays Its Pastors May Change Because of This Case

By John Harding Posted on: | April 12, 2018

To those at the Freedom From Religion Foundation (FFRF), more than 63 years of providing ministers of the gospel with tax-exempt housing is 63 years too many.

Currently, the law gives churches the ability to designate a portion of ministers’ salary for housing. That portion of their salary, which has strings attached for how it is spent, can be excluded from gross income when it comes to filing taxes.

FFRF cites the Establishment Clause of the United States Constitution (“Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion…”) as the basis for its argument against the ministerial housing allowance. But citizens across the country may wonder what religion might be established by continuing to keep the law on the books. 

Here’s the truth: Chances are, even in the next 63 years, we still won’t have an established religion as a result of this law because it actually benefits many different religions. This isn’t a law that singles out Christians, Muslims, Jews, or Sikhs for special treatment. In fact, all of those religions have ministers who benefit from this tax exemption because the IRS broadly defines “minister” to include all religious leaders.

Even though this law does not carve out special privileges for one religion, opponents of the law are still upset that houses of worship are experiencing any benefit whatsoever.

But as a 2016 study showed, the benefits that religious congregations receive does not even come close to the positive economic impact that they have on their communities. Changed lives aside, churches are known in many academic spheres to be “economic catalysts,” meaning they benefit towns and cities by multiplying the effect of every dollar that the congregation spends. The 2016 study authored by Brian and Melissa Grim estimated that religious organizations offer over $300 billion in economic value to our country each year.

Still, the hesitancy to allow churches to participate in any public benefit seems to be a recurring theme.

In fact, Alliance Defending Freedom had to go all the way to the U.S. Supreme Court last year to protect a church’s right to participate in a government benefit program that was open to all nonprofits.

Thankfully, the 7-2 Supreme Court victory in that case paved the way for policy changes that make it easier for churches to receive federal disaster relief funds. And ADF will continue to advocate for the government to treat religion as a worthy player in the public square.  

That’s why ADF will file an amicus brief in support of the minister’s housing allowance at the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit.

But we need your help! Ministers can have a voice in the matter and show their support for the housing allowance by adding their signature to the legal argument.

Since this brief may only be signed by ministers, and likely benefits your pastor (I checked, and it benefits mine), please send this article along to the ministers you know. The deadline for signing onto the brief is April 23 – so for their sakes, don’t delay!

Learn More

John Harding

Communications Specialist

John is a Grove City College graduate and serves as a communications specialist at Alliance Defending Freedom.

More from ADF View All

When the Heavy Hand of Government Gets to Decide What’s Religious and What’s Not

Religious Freedom

When the Heavy Hand of Government Gets to Decide What’s Religious and What’s Not

The government doesn’t get to classify an organization’s activities as being ...

Mr. Funny | Words | Author | I'm the icon | www | 07/18/2018 20:43:41 Read More

What Today’s Colleges Fail to Grasp about Free Speech on Campus

Religious Freedom

What Today’s Colleges Fail to Grasp about Free Speech on Campus

The idea of a university is that various disciplines can find a single space ...

Mr. Funny | Words | Author | I'm the icon | www | 07/16/2018 23:21:21 Read More

How a Proactive Defense of Freedom Took Us to the Supreme Court

Sanctity of Life

How a Proactive Defense of Freedom Took Us to the Supreme Court

We can no longer settle for playing defense when it comes to our religious fr...

Mr. Funny | Words | Author | I'm the icon | www | 07/17/2018 17:45:00 Read More

Careful, Mainstream Media, Your Anti-Catholic Bias Is Showing

Culture

Careful, Mainstream Media, Your Anti-Catholic Bias Is Showing

The religious affiliation of a judicial nominee shouldn’t matter, but the man...

Mr. Funny | Words | Author | I'm the icon | www | 07/19/2018 16:30:00 Read More