BLOGHow the Supreme Court Decides Jack Phillips’ Case Could Affect These 5 Cases

By Sarah Kramer Posted on: | February 28, 2018

Colorado cake artist Jack Phillips sits at the center of a U.S. Supreme Court case that could have profound implications for religious and artistic freedom in our country.

When Jack politely declined to design a custom cake for a same-sex wedding – an event that contradicts his faith – it was no different than when he declined to design a cake disparaging the LGBT community or a cake celebrating a divorce or a Halloween cake. Jack offered to sell the couple anything else in his store or create a cake for a different event. This is because Jack serves everyone, but he cannot express every message or help celebrate every event. As a result of Jack’s decision, the couple sued him.

Alliance Defending Freedom argued before the Supreme Court on his behalf in December. Now, the Supreme Court has the opportunity to uphold Jack’s artistic and religious freedom. If the Supreme Court does uphold these freedoms, that would be a victory for us all.

But a victory – or a loss – hits even closer to home for seven ADF clients in five different cases:

1. 303 Creative

Who: Colorado graphic designer Lorie Smith, owner of 303 Creative

What: A Colorado law, the same law being used to punish Jack, prevents Lorie from operating her business according to her faith. If Lorie designs custom websites celebrating a wedding between one man and one woman, the law also requires her to design custom websites celebrating same-sex weddings – regardless of whether that event violates her faith. Lorie is challenging this law in court.

2. Arlene’s Flowers

Who: Washington floral artist Barronelle Stutzman, owner of Arlene’s Flowers

What: The State of Washington is suing Barronelle in both her professional and personal capacity after she declined to design custom floral arrangements for the same-sex wedding of one of her longtime customers. Barronelle could not use her artistic talents to participate in an event that violated her faith. Five years later, her case is pending before the Supreme Court, and it is likely being held while the Court considers Jack Phillips’ case.

3. Brush & Nib

Who: Phoenix painter Breanna Koski and calligrapher Joanna Duka, owners of Brush & Nib Studio

What: In 2015, Breanna and Joanna opened their custom art studio. However, they found out that a Phoenix ordinance requires them to design artwork celebrating same-sex weddings if they do so for weddings between one man and one woman. The law also prohibits them from explaining their beliefs on their website, at the risk of fines and even jail time. They are challenging this law to protect their freedom to run their business consistently with their faith.

4. Hands on Originals

Who: Kentucky promotional printer Blaine Adamson, owner of Hands On Originals

What: When the Gay and Lesbian Services Organization asked Blaine to print shirts promoting the local pride festival, Blaine politely declined but offered to refer them to another shop. Because of that, he was sued. Blaine won at the state appeals court, which ruled that the government could not force him to print messages that violate his faith. The Kentucky Supreme Court has now agreed to hear the case, where support for Blaine has been overwhelming – 10 states as well as Kentucky’s governor are among the many that have filed friend-of-the-court briefs on Blaine’s behalf.

5. Telescope Media Group

Who: Minnesota filmmakers Carl and Angel Larsen, owners of Telescope Media Group

What: Telescope Media Group exists to tell great stories through film that glorify God. Carl and Angel feel called to start telling stories showing the goodness of marriage as God intended it. As they made plans to enter the wedding industry, however, they discovered that Minnesota is interpreting a state law to mean that if the Larsens tell stories about marriage that are consistent with their religious beliefs, they must tell marriage stories that violate their religious beliefs as well. Carl and Angel are challenging this law, and many others are standing behind them. Ten states have filed an amicus brief on their behalf at the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit, and a group of legal scholars has supported them as well.

Our clients simply want the freedom to express the messages and celebrate the events they choose, without fear of government punishment. Each one of our clients serve everyone, but they cannot use their artistic talents to celebrate every event. 

If the Supreme Court rules to protect Jack’s artistic and religious freedom, these other clients could also benefit from the ruling. And if these artists have that freedom, so do the rest of us.

That’s something we should all be able to get behind.

Want to know when the Supreme Court rules in Jack’s case? Get an update from the attorneys working on the case when it happens.
Send Me an Update

Sarah Kramer

Digital Content Specialist

Sarah worked as an investigative reporter before joining the Alliance Defending Freedom team.

More from ADF View All

Will You Stand With Us Against Government Threats to Our Free Speech?

Religious Freedom

Will You Stand With Us Against Government Threats to Our Free Speech?

Will you stand with us as we wait for a decision in the NIFLA case at the Sup...

Mr. Funny | Words | Author | I'm the icon | www | 03/20/2018 22:00:00 Read More

A Different Kind of March Madness at Kennesaw State University

Religious Freedom

A Different Kind of March Madness at Kennesaw State University

KSU is earning a name for itself. Unfortunately, that’s not because of its Di...

Mr. Funny | Words | Author | I'm the icon | www | 03/13/2018 20:45:58 Read More

A View from the Supreme Court: Highlights from NIFLA Oral Arguments

Sanctity of Life

A View from the Supreme Court: Highlights from NIFLA Oral Arguments

Cold rains outside the Supreme Court contrasted with the hot debate on freedo...

Mr. Funny | Words | Author | I'm the icon | www | 03/22/2018 21:28:36 Read More

Hard Truths about Divorce and Co-Parenting Demonstrate God’s Grand Design for Marriage


Hard Truths about Divorce and Co-Parenting Demonstrate God’s Grand Design for Marriage

Last week, a headline from a Time piece caught my eye: “Raising My Son With M...

Mr. Funny | Words | Author | I'm the icon | www | 03/09/2018 21:10:00 Read More