BLOGIf Your Viewpoint Is “Similar” to Someone Else’s, Should It Be Silenced?

By Sarah Kramer Posted on: | December 06, 2017

Too much of a “similar” viewpoint is a bad thing, according to officials at the University of California Berkeley. That is, unless it is a favored viewpoint.

No such favor for a group of students who wanted to start a Young Americans for Liberty (YAL) chapter on campus. When they turned in the required form to become a recognized student organization, they were denied. The reason? University officials decided they were “too similar” to another student group on campus, Cal Libertarians, and ordered that YAL work with that group rather than starting their own. YAL is quite different from Cal Libertarians, but that is beside the point—students have the right to associate together without the government favoring some groups over others.

Alliance Defending Freedom is representing YAL in a lawsuit against UC Berkeley, as its current policies allow university officials to exclude certain viewpoints from campus, while promoting others. Take these existing student organizations for instance:

  • “Cal Berkeley Democrats” and “Students for Hillary at Berkeley”
  • “Progressive Student Association” and “Socialist Alternative at Berkeley”
  • The “Queer Alliance & Resource Center,” the “Queer Student Union,” and the “UNITY Resource Center”

These groups have overlapping missions and goals. Yet, university officials recognized all of them (as well they should) while excluding YAL. 

As currently written, the university policies give unchecked power to university officials to decide which viewpoints are “too similar” and which are not – allowing them to welcome the viewpoints they favor and exclude the ones they don’t like.

This effectively silences the speech of some student groups. Since YAL is not officially recognized on campus, it cannot book meeting space, invite speakers, or use the channels of communication reserved for registered student organizations. YAL also cannot apply to receive student funding, even though every member of the group pays mandatory student fees.

That’s a violation of students’ First Amendment rights, and the ADF Center for Academic Freedom is working to ensure that this is not allowed to continue.

After all, university campuses should be a place where students can encounter any number of differing viewpoints and learn how to interact with them in a constructive way. If their university is setting a poor example of this, however, students learn that the proper way to deal with the viewpoints they don’t like is to silence them.

But if university policies promote a correct understanding of the First Amendment, students will be able to carry that understanding with them as they leave college and enter the public square.


Get the latest on the cases and issues the Center for Academic Freedom is addressing.
Learn More

Sarah Kramer

Digital Content Specialist

Sarah worked as an investigative reporter before joining the Alliance Defending Freedom team.

More from ADF View All

When the Heavy Hand of Government Gets to Decide What’s Religious and What’s Not

Religious Freedom

When the Heavy Hand of Government Gets to Decide What’s Religious and What’s Not

The government doesn’t get to classify an organization’s activities as being ...

Mr. Funny | Words | Author | I'm the icon | www | 07/18/2018 20:43:41 Read More

What Today’s Colleges Fail to Grasp about Free Speech on Campus

Religious Freedom

What Today’s Colleges Fail to Grasp about Free Speech on Campus

The idea of a university is that various disciplines can find a single space ...

Mr. Funny | Words | Author | I'm the icon | www | 07/16/2018 23:21:21 Read More

How a Proactive Defense of Freedom Took Us to the Supreme Court

Sanctity of Life

How a Proactive Defense of Freedom Took Us to the Supreme Court

We can no longer settle for playing defense when it comes to our religious fr...

Mr. Funny | Words | Author | I'm the icon | www | 07/17/2018 17:45:00 Read More

Careful, Mainstream Media, Your Anti-Catholic Bias Is Showing

Culture

Careful, Mainstream Media, Your Anti-Catholic Bias Is Showing

The religious affiliation of a judicial nominee shouldn’t matter, but the man...

Mr. Funny | Words | Author | I'm the icon | www | 07/19/2018 16:30:00 Read More